{
  "schemaVersion": 1,
  "kind": "published-QCD-simulation-correction-comparison",
  "source": "CMS arXiv:2111.10431v3 section 4.3 Eq. (4), bounded central-rapidity slice of Fig. 5a; HEPData115022v2 t49/t41",
  "scope": "Recalculate the published nonperturbative model envelope and its multiplication by the separately published electroweak factor for the frozen 22-bin measured channel.",
  "nonperturbativeDefinition": "sigma_MC(PS+MPI+HAD)/sigma_MC(PS)",
  "modelVersions": [
    "PYTHIA 8 CP1",
    "HERWIG++ EE5C"
  ],
  "limitations": [
    "Envelope endpoints are not individually identified as a particular generator.",
    "Published smooth correction factors are used; no shower, hadronization or fixed-order calculation is rerun.",
    "The EW table supplies no uncertainty; a zero hidden error is not evidence of zero theory uncertainty.",
    "Measured cross sections and simulation correction factors remain separate columns; the products are dimensionless theory corrections, not new measurements."
  ],
  "firstBinCombinedCentral": 0.964468584,
  "lastBinCombinedCentral": 1.084711416,
  "rows": [
    {
      "binGeV": [
        97.0,
        133.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 9375.9,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.96555,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.9293910000000001,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 1.001709,
      "electroweak": 0.99888,
      "combinedCentral": 0.964468584,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 0.92835008208,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 1.00058708592
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        133.0,
        174.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 2186.6,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.96723,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.936018,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.998442,
      "electroweak": 0.99814,
      "combinedCentral": 0.9654309522000001,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 0.93427700652,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 0.99658489788
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        174.0,
        220.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 604.76,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.96877,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.941469,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.996071,
      "electroweak": 0.99722,
      "combinedCentral": 0.9660768194,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 0.93885171618,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 0.99330192262
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        220.0,
        272.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 187.91,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.9702,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.9461299999999999,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.99427,
      "electroweak": 0.99609,
      "combinedCentral": 0.966406518,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 0.9424306317,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 0.9903824043
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        272.0,
        330.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 62.72,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.97153,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.950216,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.9928440000000001,
      "electroweak": 0.99487,
      "combinedCentral": 0.9665460511,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 0.94534139192,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 0.98775071028
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        330.0,
        395.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 22.311,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.97277,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.9538570000000001,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.991683,
      "electroweak": 0.99342,
      "combinedCentral": 0.9663691734,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 0.9475806209400001,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 0.9851577258599999
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        395.0,
        468.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 8.3961,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.97394,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.9571660000000001,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.990714,
      "electroweak": 0.99216,
      "combinedCentral": 0.9663043104000001,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 0.9496618185600001,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 0.98294680224
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        468.0,
        548.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 3.2454,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.97504,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.9601810000000001,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.989899,
      "electroweak": 0.991,
      "combinedCentral": 0.96626464,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 0.9515393710000001,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 0.9809899089999999
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        548.0,
        638.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 1.3009,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.97609,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.96297,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.98921,
      "electroweak": 0.99038,
      "combinedCentral": 0.9667000142000001,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 0.9537062286,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 0.9796937998
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        638.0,
        737.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 0.52736,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.97708,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.96556,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.9885999999999999,
      "electroweak": 0.98994,
      "combinedCentral": 0.9672505752,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 0.9558464664,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 0.978654684
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        737.0,
        846.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 0.21823,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.97803,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.9679789999999999,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.988081,
      "electroweak": 0.9903,
      "combinedCentral": 0.968543109,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 0.9585896036999999,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 0.9784966142999999
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        846.0,
        967.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 0.091758,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.97893,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.9702462,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.9876138,
      "electroweak": 0.99188,
      "combinedCentral": 0.9709810884,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 0.9623678008559999,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 0.979594375944
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        967.0,
        1101.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 0.03788,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.97981,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.9724098,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.9872101999999999,
      "electroweak": 0.99422,
      "combinedCentral": 0.9741466982,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 0.966789271356,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 0.9815041250439999
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        1101.0,
        1248.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 0.015827,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.98065,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.9744551,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.9868449,
      "electroweak": 0.99808,
      "combinedCentral": 0.978767152,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 0.9725841462079999,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 0.984950157792
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        1248.0,
        1410.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 0.006544,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.98145,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.9763900000000001,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.98651,
      "electroweak": 1.0034,
      "combinedCentral": 0.9847869300000001,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 0.9797097260000002,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 0.9898641340000001
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        1410.0,
        1588.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 0.0026946,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.98223,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.9782448,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.9862152000000001,
      "electroweak": 1.0109,
      "combinedCentral": 0.9929363069999999,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 0.98890766832,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 0.9969649456799999
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        1588.0,
        1784.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 0.0010254,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.98299,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.9800262000000001,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.9859538,
      "electroweak": 1.0203,
      "combinedCentral": 1.002944697,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 0.9999207318600001,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 1.00596866214
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        1784.0,
        2000.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 0.00040474,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.98372,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.981732,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.985708,
      "electroweak": 1.0312,
      "combinedCentral": 1.0144120639999998,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 1.0123620384,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 1.0164620895999998
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        2000.0,
        2238.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 0.0001539,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.98443,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.9833771,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.9854829,
      "electroweak": 1.0458,
      "combinedCentral": 1.0295168940000001,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 1.0284157711800002,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 1.03061801682
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        2238.0,
        2500.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 5.2173e-05,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.98513,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.98497505,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.9852849499999999,
      "electroweak": 1.0608,
      "combinedCentral": 1.0450259039999998,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 1.04486153304,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 1.04519027496
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        2500.0,
        2787.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 1.5438e-05,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.9858,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.98509294,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.98650706,
      "electroweak": 1.0776,
      "combinedCentral": 1.06229808,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 1.0615361521439999,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 1.063060007856
    },
    {
      "binGeV": [
        2787.0,
        3103.0
      ],
      "publishedMeasuredPbPerGeV": 4.728e-06,
      "nonperturbativeCentral": 0.98646,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeLower": 0.9849234,
      "nonperturbativeEnvelopeUpper": 0.9879966,
      "electroweak": 1.0996,
      "combinedCentral": 1.084711416,
      "combinedEnvelopeLower": 1.0830217706399998,
      "combinedEnvelopeUpper": 1.08640106136
    }
  ]
}